Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Chicken Tenders
Steak Hoagie
Homemade Alfredo With Pasta
Hamburger Deluxe
About
Pontillo's Pizzeria Cortland
Welcome to Pontillo's Pizzeria Cortland, a cherished gem nestled in the heart of Cortland, NY, at 124 Groton Ave. This family-owned establishment has been a staple in the community, serving up delicious pizzas and mouthwatering wings that keep both locals and visitors coming back for more. With a commitment to quality and service, Pontillo's embodies the warmth of a family gathering around the dinner table.
As you step inside, you’re greeted not just by the aroma of freshly baked pizza but also by a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Customers rave about the exceptional flavor and crispiness of their wings, while the pizzas are highlighted for their freshness and balanced toppings. One visitor, Aj Puma, from California, exclaimed that the pizza was "amazing" and declared Pontillo's a must-visit for anyone in town.
But it’s not just the food that makes Pontillo's special; it's the people. Customer service shines here, with friendly servers like Jody ensuring a pleasant dining experience, even during late-night visits. The restaurant makes an effort to ensure every need is met, enhancing the overall dining experience. It's this kind of attentive service that keeps patrons like Jeff Poltorak returning, as he fondly recalls the memories made over family meals at Pontillo's throughout the years.
While some menu items may surprise—like the buffalo chicken salad being predominantly iceberg lettuce—the overall feedback highlights that the culinary offerings at Pontillo’s are consistently high quality. Brooke Williams noted that the pizza was cooked just right, remaining hot and fresh when delivered.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Pontillo's Pizzeria Cortland offers not just a meal but a slice of family tradition infused with Italian flavor. With its steadfast commitment to quality, customer satisfaction, and a menu that pleases the palate, it's easy to see why this pizzeria has carved a niche in the hearts of its patrons. If you're in Cortland, a visit to Pontillo's is not just recommended; it's essential!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The wings had great flavor and were very crispy. The buffalo chicken salad was mostly a big bowl of iceberg lettuce, so that was kind of disappointing. Our server Jody was excellent and very helpful even though we arrived somewhat late in the evening. Part of the kitchen closes at 9pm so you can't order everything till 10pm so make sure you plan accordingly. ”
“ Being not from the area and our Airbnb hosts owning the place we decided to try it out. The food was awesome. We got looks from the locals() bc southern accents in Upstate NY but it is what it is. They were super nice, made sure we had what we needed and the food was AWESOME! ”
“ Grew up coming here. It's a family staple. Sitting in the restaurant brought back great memories. Great family owned restaurant. ”
“ In town fom California on business so was my first time visiting Pontillo's. Let me tell you this pizza was amazing. If you're ever in town its a must stop. I know I'll be coming again before I leave town. ”
“ Food was phenomenal. Quality looked fresh and food was still hot! Pizza tasted great and there wasn't too much grease. Wings were great as ever. Delivery service was fast. Will definitely order again in the future. ”
“ Pontillo's was welcoming of our large group and the food and service was fantastic! The manager and servers were great! ”
“ I placed an order for pickup. It was ready very quickly. The service was incredible, the workers were very kind. I drove all the way back home to enjoy some of the best wings I have ever had. Not tough, they are fall off the bone and the sauce is delicious. If I could rate higher, I would! Phenomenal! ”
“ What a great Italian restaurant. I enjoyed the chicken Parm, my kids enjoyed a pizza, and we were all well cared for by the service team. ”